2022 Toyota GR86 GT vs 1986 Toyota AE86 Sprinter GTV comparison

Oct 25, 2023

A lyrebird cackles from within the bright lilac ferns somewhere nearby, while I try to convince myself the slowly wafting smoke is from the brakes.

Brakes that smell, peculiarly, like bushfire. Brakes that were hardly used while hammering uphill in this underpowered 1986 buzz box, trying to keep up with a new Toyota GR86.

As we reach the top of the winding Donna Buang Road east of Melbourne, the smoke seems to have subsided as we lift the heavy steel bonnet to find a crispy eucalyptus leaf attempting self-immolation by means of wedging itself between cylinders two and three of a 35-year-old cast iron exhaust manifold. The leaf is extracted, and there is relief.

Today, no cars are burning to the ground, but it is a fiery undertaking no less: we’re comparing new versus old, 1986 Toyota AE86 Sprinter GTV versus 2022 Toyota GR86 GT. The objective: to see if Toyota has imbued more AE86 DNA into the second iteration of its rear-drive sports car.

The first version, as released in 2012, was more an adopted than direct descendent of Toyota's cult classic AE86. The Toyota 86 and its Subaru BRZ twin were both brilliant in their own right – enough to win Wheels Car of the Year 2012, no less – but failed to rekindle some of the spark of the 1980s original.

Namely, under the bonnet, the FA20 2.0-litre boxer four-cylinder titillates in a way a new dishwasher might: undoubtedly useful, initially exciting even, but ultimately a thing of function than desire.

Torque is also up – by 38Nm to 250Nm – and peaks earlier in the rev range (3700rpm versus 6600rpm), addressing a major complaint of the previous model. As well as a new, much more handsome cabin, there's now an interior engine noise speaker, producing a sweeter sound (even if it's more stevia than sugar).

In order to properly understand the new car, though, we must first understand the old. On the surface, the AE86 is simply a rear-drive Toyota Corolla from the 1980s – hobbled by prodigious hype. But forget its enormous cult following and you discover something special – something of a Japanese BDA-powered Ford Escort.

From the driver's seat, the AE86 is light and airy courtesy of its thin pillars and large windows. The interior is classic 1980s Toyota, a tub of cheap plastics, urethane and vinyl. There is a faint smell of tobacco like seemingly every other eighties and nineties Japanese imported car.

The charms of weighing just 950kg and being rear-drive are obvious enough, yet it's the 4AGE engine that is the AE86's real secret sauce. In the 1980s, a twin-cam, 16-valve 1587cc inline-four – revving to 7700rpm from the factory – was something to be celebrated (even if it only had 96kW and 149Nm to show for it).

It doesn't like to be rushed in producing that power, either. While stationary, a blip of the lovely cable throttle generates an angry spike of revs – like a motorbike, which makes sense given Yamaha had a hand in developing the 4AGE. But on the move, in second gear and beyond, the 4AGE winds patiently through a long arc of revs, making quite the song in the process.

Call me biased – this is my personal car – but the AE86 is a delight to drive. Refreshingly mechanical, the entire car buzzes with feedback. It takes a while to build momentum – like a freight train – and once it's going, every km/h feels precious.

In this particular car, with aftermarket coil-overs and 2.5 degrees of negative front camber, it's all about carrying as much speed into the corners as you dare – and it can carry quite a lot. Enough to startle a brand-new GR86, to be sure.

Meanwhile, get an AE86 with a limited-slip diff on a wet or dirt road, and it’ll take about six corners to see why they are loved by drifters and rally drivers alike.

Getting out of an AE86 and into a GR86 must be like a pilot jumping from a Spitfire into a Joint Strike Fighter. You sit lower and are much more cocooned. It feels much bigger and wider. The cloth seats of the lower-spec GT, too, are a delight.

Start extending that bigger bore FA24 and, compared to the AE86's characterful 4AGE, the artificial engine noise coming through the speakers is certainly loud and interesting, but not quite to our tastes. Others seem to like it – horses for courses.

The trade-off for the artificial noise is strong power (172kW from a 2.4-litre atmo four would have blown everybody's little minds just 20 years ago).

It's easy to access second-gear throttle steer, too, even in the dry.

Quirkily, the GR86 feels noticeably more rigid than the previous model – like it's got a newly-installed, invisible 10-point roll cage. For chassis rigidity, it would make a 2012 car feel like a convertible – and that car was hardly wobbly.

Obviously, the GR86 is night-and-day faster than an AE86. Whereas the AE86 is all about maximising mid-corner speed, the GR86 is about not overcooking it. In fact, it could handle much better rubber than its standard Michelin Primacy tyres, which require you to over-slow the car into most corners.

They’re not the most communicative or linear of tyres, either. Replacing them with something like Michelin Pilot Sport 4S would make a big difference to the GR86 GT's driver appeal.

The GR86 feels engineered for oversteer, too. Into corners, the rear-end is nervous and flighty, almost like an old school hot hatch – and you’re constantly reacting to it.

In terms of chassis communication, the GR86 asks you to listen carefully. The steering is razor sharp, and there's okay feel, but all the other controls leave you somewhat working out where the limit might be.

The AE86, by comparison, communicates the road and what the chassis is doing with perfect clarity – although, it must be said, it does this at all times. Some Melbourne roads, you don't want to know too well…

It's not that the GR86 is much better, being fairly bumpy with lots of tyre noise by modern sports car standards.

The throttle map has a big bulge right at the start of its travel, as if engineered to try to further mask any lack of low-down torque. It gets tiring constantly having to sensitively feed in throttle in traffic.

Its clutch is also still a bit numb and the dry, notchy gearshift isn't anything special. Then there's the price – just 12 months ago, a (previous-generation) 86 GT cost $32,180. It's now $43,420.

Toyota would argue it has a lot more standard equipment – and, to be fair, the interior represents a big step up, and not just because nobody's been smoking in this one. Also, it's still cheaper than the $70,000 or so the red AE86 would now set you back...

Flawed as it might be as a daily driver, the GR86 is a much better sports car. It's finally got the grunt it should have had in the first place. And it looks a lot better – one of the more accomplished facelifts of late. The GR86, like the new BRZ as well, gets under your skin in a way only a rear-drive sports car can.

However, while Toyota has built a better sports car, like the 2012 car it's still fairly bereft of any noticeable AE86 DNA or lineage. With totally different engine characters, they remain more family friends than close relatives.

That's not to say the GR86 failed in rekindling an old flame, it just ignited something new.

Something that won't have you fumbling around for a fire extinguisher.

Dylan Campbell is a former Editor of Wheels and MOTOR, and currently serves as a Wheels Car of the Year judge.